The (Mostly) True Origins of Britain’s Many Pies

There’s something special about pies in Britain, whatever your choice of filling we’re guaranteed to have put it in a pie crust at least once, and many of these have stuck around with us for the long haul. With pies so closely tied to British cooking, it’s easy to think they’ve always been here, but where did they come from? Each pie has its own origin story, and they’re as unique as the people that eat them! We’re taking a closer look at just a few of these flaky beauties to see just who came up with them.

Pork Pie’s Sweet Origins

Is there anything more British than a pork pie? We love them so much we even named a hat after them, but it might surprise you to know that one of our earliest pork pie recipes was actually a desert! Traditionally eaten around Christmas time, a recipe for flampontynes appears in the 14th century book ‘The Forme of Cury’ written by and for chefs in King Richard II’s court. A pork and cheese pie might not seem like typical desert faire, but they also included ginger, cinnamon, sugar, and plenty of other spices to sweeten it.

Other pies in ‘The Forme of Cury’ (called ‘coffyns’ at the time) included other sweet additions to the meat, like dried currants and dates. This was back when ‘mincemeat’ was literal! Nowadays we might skip the cinnamon when making our pork pies, but when you bite into one, it’s nice to know they’re fit for a king.

As British as… Apple Pie?

Despite the oft-repeated adage, it turns out we beat the Americans to the punch on the apple pie. We have another 14th century writer to thank for recording this classic sweet treat, but this time we have a name to put against it, and what a name it is! Famed poet Goeffrey Chaucer of ‘The Canterbury Tales’ fame took some time out of his schedule to record a recipe for Tartys in Applis that sounds as good today as it did back then. With apples, pears, figs and a hearty selection of spices, it’s easy to see how this pie became such a mainstay both here and across the pond. In Chaucer’s time the pastry wasn’t meant to be edible, so while we definitely have much to thank him for, let’s also give a thanks to bakers past, present and future for continuing to improve on this classic pie.

Stargazy Pie From a Legendary Fisherman

Pork and apple pies too mainstream for you? Looking for something more unique? Well look no further than the Cornish stargazy pie, with a recipe as creative as its origins. This distinctive pie that uses the whole fish looking up to star gaze out of the crust originated in Mousehole, Cornwall. You might be wondering when this pie was created, and well, that depends on how you feel about the legend of Tom Bawcock. According to legend, Tom was a local fisherman in the 16th century. As it goes, the village was suffering a terrible and drawn-out storm that had the fishermen stuck in the docks, meaning the locals were starving. Braving the storm, brave Tom set out into the choppy waters and returned with enough fish for everyone in the village. His entire catch, including all 7 types of fish he’d reeled in, got baked into a single pie for a village feast. The heads of the fish were left sticking out of the pie to reassure the villagers that every fish was included. Ever since then, Mousehole celebrates Tom Bawcock’s Eve every 23rd December by baking a huge stargazy pie, enough for everyone to have a slice.

Pies For All Time

With so much history behind our love of pie, there’s little surprise there’s so many incredible varieties to choose from today. So if you’re looking to celebrate the classics or try something new, let’s all raise a crust to pies past, present, and future. The best is surely yet to come!