Perfect Pie Pairings To Chase Away the Winter Blues

Here at British Pie Week we’re all about pies year ‘round, but there’s something extra special about a nice hot pie when it’s chilly out. Whether you want to warm up by the fire while you take in this year’s rerun of Die Hard or Muppet’s Christmas Carol, or you’re looking to impress at a big party, in our totally unbiased opinion a pie is the perfect choice! Still, a perfect pie needs a perfect partner, so read below for our recommendations for drinks and side-dishes to truly get you into the spirit of the season!

Chicken Pot Pie

Coming in out of the cold and need something cozy but simple? You can whip up a lovely chicken pot pie surprisingly quick, often in as little as 30mins. Chicken pot pie is warming and fluffy, which means it’s the perfect match for some creamy mashed potatoes and a rich, buttery chardonnay. It’s the perfect winter comfort food, warm and comforting without being too heavy, so you won’t need to feel guilty about having it all to yourself as a treat. With a simple recipe and few ingredients, you can easily make this pie at all kinds of sizes, all the way from a full pie for everyone to share down to tiny little ramakin pies as a treat, or the perfect fun addition to a buffet-style party meal.

Cottage or Shepherd’s Pie

Whether you’re a beef or a lamb fan, these two pies earned their stripes as winter staples. Filling, rich, and best made in a big portion so that everyone can grab a plate (or so that you can enjoy it over a couple days), cottage and shepherd’s pie are the perfect treat after being out and about in the cold all day. Of course, they’re already renowned for being a whole meal in themselves, including mashed potatoes and lashings of veg, so all that’s needed is a perfect drink. Why not try your pie with some port? Many of the posher recipes for these two similar pies will include port, but it can also be the perfect pairing, and a small dram won’t take up much room after a generous helping of pie!

Lancashire Cheese & Onion Pie

If you’re searching for a vegetarian option, this Cheese & Onion pie from up North may be just the ticket. Don’t let the vegetarian label dissuade you, this is hearty, filling pie that’ll make a perfect treat while you’re sat around the fire. Now of course you’ll want some rich vegetables to balance this pie out, but when it comes to a drink pairing, that’ll be up to your inner sommelier! Cheese and wine are a famously natural pairing, but depending on which cheese you use, you’ll want to find a wine that pairs just right. If you want something crisp to compliment the creamy cheese, try a Sauvignon Blanc, or if you want to bring the accompanying vegetables to the fore, why not pair it with Pinot Noir to emphasise that rich, earthy flavour.

Mince Pie

It’s not just the main course that you can perfectly satisfy with our favourite baked good, and if you happen to be visiting from the North Pole you’ll probably be well aware of this classic pairing. Making your own mince pies can really finish up a party or Christmas meal with a bang, and while the classic hand-held mince pie is a wonderful treat, consider making a full sized mince pie to really emphasise the warmth and spices, and ensure nobody goes home hungry! Now while there’s plenty of debate on what kind of cream you take your mince pies with, anyone who’s made their way down a chimney or two knows that the ideal drink is a classic sweet, dry sherry will be the perfect pairing for a mince pie that’s been treated to a healthy helping of cream. If you’re not feeling like alcohol though, a nice hot cocoa is the perfect winter warmer to treat yourself to!

Start Your Own Tradition

Hopefully this little guide will give you something new to try as the leaves start to fall and the windows get frosty, but don’t let it hold you back! There’s always time to try something new, and who knows, perhaps next year we’ll be writing about a perfect pairing you’ve found!