Pie Failures & How to Fix Them: Troubleshooting Common Savoury Pie Problems 🤔
Savoury pies can be made and loved by anyone; however, even the most experienced bakers experience pie failures. But don’t worry, there is always a way to rescue them without ruining your pie.Â
Soggy BottomÂ
If your pastry base is pale, soft, or undercooked, I’m afraid you have a soggy bottom, and no one likes a soggy bottom, especially when you have spent all that time creating a delicious pie. 😢 This can happen when there is too much moisture in the filling, or you haven’t baked the pie for long enough. Don’t panic! There are ways to prevent a soggy bottom right from the start, including:Â
Blind bake the base before adding filling – this ensures the base is fully cooked right through and you have the perfect pie base.Â
Brush the base with beaten egg or melted butter to create a moisture barrier – this stops any liquid filling absorbing into the base, ensuring it cooks and doesn’t go soggy.Â
Bake on a preheated baking tray for extra bottom heat – this adds an extra layer of heat to ensure the base bakes perfectly.Â
Avoid over-wet fillings – wet fillings create the risk of a soggy bottom as the pastry can absorb the liquid. Make sure to drain or reduce any excess liquid to avoid this.Â
Cracked or Tough PastryÂ
If your pastry crust becomes cracked, dense or chewy, you may have over-mixed, not added enough fat, or added too much flour when rolling out the dough. Hey! It happens to the best of us, but you can fix this by:Â
Using cold butter and handling lightly – this ensures the pastry dough mixes well and doesn’t make it tough.Â
Adding a teaspoon of vinegar or lemon juice – this helps to make the dough tender.Â
Roll the pastry out between two sheets of parchment paper – this is an alternative to adding extra flour, which could cause the pastry to crack or become tough.Â
Pastry Shrinking Away From the TinÂ
Quite often, people find that their pie pastry shrinks away from the tin or collapses when baking. Frustrating, we know! 😡 This means that your pastry was either over-worked or stretched when being rolled out. To prevent this from happening, you can:Â
Chill your dough thoroughly before baking – this solidifies any fat and relaxes the gluten, meaning when baked, it won’t shrink.Â
Don’t stretch your pie pastry – whether that’s whilst rolling it out or placing it in the tin, stretching it causes the pastry to shrink when baked. Instead, lightly press the pastry when putting it in the tin.Â
Place your tin in the fridge before baking – this cools down the tin and keeps the pastry cooler for longer. If it heats too quickly, there is a higher chance of shrinking.Â
Overcooked Lids & Undercooked CentresÂ
It can be disheartening when you think you have baked the perfect pie, but then discover the filling is still raw, and you may want to throw it away and give up altogether. This can happen when your oven temperature is too high or when there is an uneven heat distribution. We’ve got you covered, though! 🙌 To fix thi,s you can:Â
Lower the oven temperature slightly and bake for longer – this ensures the pie is cooked through whilst creating the perfect golden top.Â
Cover the top of the pie with foil halfway through baking – this will prevent the top from burning and ensure the centre is baked through.Â
Check internal temperatures – checking the temperature of the centre of your pie ensures that it is being cooked. 75 degrees Celsius is the desired temperature for meat pies.Â
Â
If you follow these tips, you will create the perfect, delicious, golden, savoury pie, avoiding all mishaps. When you’re done baking, send us a picture of your delicious pie for a chance to feature on our socials!Â